© 2015 All materials on this site are the property of the site owners and may not be removed or used without written permission.
Changing the actions, aptitudes and attitudes of dogs and their people
I Am My Dog’s Leader
When our sheep are lambing we add grain to their diet. Once a day in the evening we go out to the barn on the ATV
and feed them. We fill buckets with corn and carry them to the feeders and pour it into the plastic troughs. Within a
few days, no matter what time of day it might be, the sound of the ATV sets them into a frenzy, racing to the barn,
bleating, carrying on as if they are starving. The sight of my husband or me carrying a bucket across the yard will
send them racing back to the barn, for they can actually see us from several hundred yards away from the house.
The sound of corn pouring into a bucket or into a plastic trough will result in the same response, even if it is early in
the day and they are not the intended recipients of the grain. Within a week of beginning their added nutrition, I get
the feeling that they perceive me as one huge corn cob.
A couple weeks before the lambs are to be weaned, we begin to reduce the corn in their diet until they are receiving
no additional grain on the day we take their lambs from them. The process of reducing their caloric intake helps
them through weaning and the eventual complete lack of lactation. By the time the lambs are weaned, the sound of
the ATV, the image of my husband walking with a grain bucket, or the sound of pouring grain no longer elicits the
frenzied bleating or racing to the barn. The triggers no longer are followed by the reward and the behavior is
Even though our sheep are crazy about eating corn, I have learned that I cannot count on using grain to get them to
go where I want them to go. Regardless of how hungry they may be, they will not follow me with a bucket of grain if
they simply do not want to do so.
We use herding dogs to manage our sheep, and even if the sheep are greedily eating their dinner, the dogs can make
them move off the feeders if we instruct them to do so. That is because the sheep have learned to respect the dogs.
When necessary, the dogs will “punish” a sheep that is not staying in line. Herding dogs nip sheep that are
challenging the dog’s authority and are not moving where the dog is directing them to go. The worse the challenge
from the sheep - the harder the grip will be. A ram that maliciously charges a dog can expect a much harder grip
than a ewe that is merely trying to double back to the grain or hay. This ability to measure the correction is
programmed into a well bred herding dog. The sheep learn that they can avoid a nip by complying with the dog’s
demands and they understand that the punishment fits the crime, so to speak. So, they do not panic at the sight of
the dog, they simply assume the posture of well seasoned students lining up to go indoors after recess.
There is a contemporary method of dog training that is strongly based on using treats to reward specific behaviors.
This, in and of itself is not a bad thing. But, like our sheep at weaning time, when the treat goes away, so may the
behavior. The method was developed in the captive aquatic mammal realm, where dolphin trainers were attempting
to get their wild subjects to perform circus tricks. Since a killer whale, walrus or a porpoise cannot be physically
controlled, and because it has no natural affinity to subordinate to human keepers, they needed a way to
communicate their pleasure when the animals performed natural behaviors. It is now used routinely by wild animal
trainers in performance areas like the motion picture industry or animal theme parks.
At some point, a dolphin trainer decided to try the method with her domestic dog. Through good marketing, the
technique has become quite popular, sometimes referred to as “click and treat” or “all positive” training. The method
is not based on leadership, loyalty or genetically programmed subordination. It does not acknowledge the
thousands of years of genetic selection that we have designed into our domestic dogs. It works for pretty much any
species with a nervous system. It disregards the very unique status of dog, and puts him in the same category as a
porpoise or a grizzly bear.
To perform the method, you just need a stimulus (the sound of the ATV for our sheep, or perhaps a small clicker
device for a dog, a whistle for a porpoise) and you need to pair that with the treat (corn for our sheep, a piece of
hotdog for your pup, a mackerel for the dolphin). First, you teach the animal that the sound is associated with the
treat. The sound of the ATV engine preceding the sound of pouring grain worked for our sheep. Dolphin trainers
whistle and then toss a fish at the dolphin’s smiling face. You click then offer the hotdog to your pup. Once the
animal has figured out that the sound is associated with the treat you can begin to use that sound to inform the
animal that you are happy with a particular behavior when the animal presents it. You wait for the animal to perform
the desired response (a dolphin jumping out of the water, a bear standing on his hind legs, a chicken scratching her
head, a lizard licking his eyeball) and then you click or whistle to inform the animal that behavior was “good”. Upon
hearing the sound, the animal’s brain says “yummy!”, he comes to get his goodie, and you give it to him! This
reinforces the behavior. The animal may then choose to perform the behavior again to see if it can get the reward
once more. If you click or whistle again as the animal is exhibiting the behavior, you begin to reinforce the behavior.
Then, you can begin to pair a command (hand signal or voice command) to try to “control” when the animal performs
the behavior. It is a method that works on dolphins, bears, chickens, sheep and even lizards because it is based on a
response that is found in animals with central nervous systems!
But, in the same way that the sheep consider me a big cob of corn and have no sense of respect for me or a need to
do my bidding, dogs that are trained exclusively with this method begin to view their human as a big hotdog, or a
gumball machine filled with Jerky Treats. This method completely excludes the use of negative re-enforcers for
behaviors that you find objectionable. It excludes the concept of punishing bad behaviors and only relies on the
learning that takes place when a dog chooses to present a behavior and when the dog wants to receive a goodie. If
the reward begins to loose meaning, the behavior may begin to extinguish. A dog that is not food motivated, is not
hungry, or just doesn’t care to play the game will not comply. The method does not utilize the thousands of years of
designed selection that have gone into creating modern dog. There is no need for a special relationship with the
animal. I find that a real shame, since the whole point of that selection was to make the training and management of
dogs easy, and to make living with a dog far superior to living with, say, a Brown Bear.
The clicker method works well for teaching dogs to do tricks or to do behaviors that are not based on compliance. If
you want to teach a dog to walk up a ladder, using the click and treat method is a good choice because the behaviors
can be broken down into many steps, the dog can be rewarded for the little steps and then for adding steps
together. Tricks usually have no meaning to the dog, so the click and treat method can be used successfully, albeit it
is not the only possible method. And, depending on the dog, it may not be the best method, to accomplish that task.
In my opinion, the clicker method does not work well to extinguish existing “bad” behaviors. The method actually
ignores half of the learning strategies that animals (including us humans) use to survive in the world. Avoiding
negative events based on receiving uncomfortable responses for the behavior is a valid method for training animals,
including humans. In fact, the ability to avoid discomfort is a basis for many behaviors. When used appropriately
and fairly, it puts the animal in complete control of his own destiny, resulting in a very confident dog. When he
knows the ramification of a behavior and he can avoid it by controlling his own behavior, the dog develops into a self-
assured animal with a heightened loyalty for his leader (who he sees as a deliverer of information about the rules of
We have twelve dogs. It’s a pack, one could say. It is comprised of dogs as young as 6 months old and as old as
thirteen. There are intact males and neutered ones. There are intact females and spayed ones. We have dogs that
are rescues that are obvious results of poor early management. They tend to lack some basic dog social skills that
the pups we have raised seem to exude. We have dogs that we have bred or raised ourselves that appear to have
good dog-social skills.
I often watch my dogs play in the yard. They are constantly reminding each other of their rank in the pack. For
example, Breeze (a neutered, nine year old male) and Sage (a two year old, intact male) are very good at peace
keeping. Several times in an hour they might be seen running up to certain dogs and licking them under the chin to
affirm, at least it seems, that they are still “cool” with the more dominant dog. They also perform calming type
behaviors (like yawning, turning their eyes away, bowing) when there are little uprising amongst the dogs. And, yet,
at the same time, when a subordinate dog or pup acts too silly, they are the first to take the youngster’s muzzle in
their own jaws and clamp down at the perfectly appropriate level to demand the sort of respect that the pup failed to
I have also seen a dog demand a “down-stay” from a subordinate, putting the dog in its place and then reinforcing
that position for some period of time by the turning up of a lip, showing of teeth, staring down the subordinate,
uttering a low growl or even physically punishing it with a nip. I see this turf control when we have dogs in the house,
as well. Much of the dog-on-dog communication that I observe is based on punishment, or avoiding it. It does not
rely upon seeking rewards from other dogs. Certainly, when two or more dogs are playing it appears that they are
“getting” something good from the other dog, but the obvious communication between dogs appears to be based on
negative reinforcement, not the “all positive” training that is so in vogue today.
Along with playing games of “keep-away”, “chase-Me!” or “I’m gonna chase you”, dogs spend a lot of their time
establishing rules, enforcing them, avoiding getting punished by another, making peace to avoid getting punished by
showing subordination, and peace keeping behaviors that usually include measured “corrections” for the dog that
steps over the line. Dogs understand that language. It makes sense to them. It works for them. They appear
happiest when all the players know the rules and play by them. So, I use that approach in my dog training. It makes
sense to me to do so.
I want to be my dog’s ultimate leader, not a hotdog dispensing machine. Using their own language that is heavily
based on providing rules, setting boundaries, enforcing those lines, correcting the negative behaviors when
necessary with fair and measured feedback; those approaches go a very long way in establishing a comfortable
environment for the dog. Most “behavior problems” fall into the “extinguish an existing behavior” column, not the
“create a new behavior” bucket. So, using a correction based method makes sense, is fast, fair, and highly
understandable for the dog. Once the dog recognizes me as his very faithful and competent leader, learning of the
other behaviors or tricks (where we can use treats, toys or even lures and bribes) goes quickly and smoothly.
© 2005 Tammie Rogers - all rights reserved. For permission to reprint email
B/T Enrollment Form
Classes: One Day Workshop
Border Collie Puppies
METHODS & PHILOSOPHY
What Makes A Happy Dog?
When Board/Train is the better option
Can you train my 8 week old puppy?
Dealing with a Thunder phobic dog
Training a fearful dog
Selecting a breed as a Service Dog
How To Select A Dog Trainer
I am my dog's leader
Why do dogs need leadership?
Choosing the right breed for your lifestyle
Personality vs. Behavior
How to research a breeder
Crate training issues
Discussing breed standards
Response to a critique of our methods
How to acquire a puppy
How Can I Become a Breeder?
Dogs Must Die
Q & A
Need Help! with my rescue puppy
Transferring Training Commands
Did I buy a puppy that is too young?
Help! My puppy is biting!
What breed should I get?
Teaching older dog to accept puppy
How do I correct my pitbull?
How do we evidence training?
Does my dog need obedience or a hobby?
Will my dog revert after professional training
Rescue Syndrome or housebreaking problem?
Will my dog still run away?
An issue with kids and dogs
Will training break my dogs spirit?